Another book review this week. People seem to like book reviews and this book is a thriller set in Victorian London, so it seems an appropriate thing to show up here. And it may even encourage people to review their own choice of thriller set in Victorian London. Not that I have anything in particular in mind.
Anyway, the publishers sent me a copy of Blackstone and the Rendezvous with Death by Sally Spencer and asked if I could maybe write something about it. Because reviews are really important to getting a book out there in a crowded market. Have I mentioned that?
So here is my review. If you were to write a review (for Amazon, say), it wouldn't have to be nearly as long as this. You could just say that Victorian thrillers are great. People should buy them. Especially if you can get them on Kindle for just £2.82/$3.99 at
mybook.to/BackHome.
Anyway, to business:
Blackstone and the Rendezvous with Death
Blackstone and the Rendezvous with Death
is set in the year of Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee: 1897. It's a crime
thriller which travels from the East End to the homes of the aristocracy as
Inspector Blackstone struggles to solve the mystery of an aristocrat’s son who was
found murdered on an insalubrious stretch of the River Thames. Issues of class
and poverty feature prominently in the story, so, having just written Back Home, a story of crime and violence
in the London slums of 1859 where issues of class and poverty are also pretty
central, I expected to be on familiar ground.
I was
reminded, yet again, just what an era of change the late 19th century was. 1897
is often seen as the height of the Victorian era, but we are moving much more
into Edwardian times. I was constantly taken aback by the modernity of the
story. People are always on the telephone and at one stage using a telephone
box. There is a reference to a Remington typewriting machine that looks at
least twenty years old. Horseless carriages are referred to as
automobiles. I was sure these were
anachronisms, but a quick tour of the Internet proved that they were not.
Admittedly Blackstone does seem to be on the cutting edge of things. Remington
typewriters have been around but very little more than twenty years. There
weren't very many telephone boxes or automobiles. But Sally Spencer seems to
know her stuff. The only apparent error I picked up was a mistake in the
licensing laws, which unfortunately occurs right at the beginning of the book
and made me unduly suspicious of the rest of it. Still, pub closing times were
a complex area with different rules for different kinds of pub and frequent
changes in the law, so perhaps she is right and I am wrong.
The
important thing is not that Ms Spencer seems to be well ahead on the game of
"try to catch the author out": it is that her thorough grounding in
the detail of the period reflects the confidence with which she takes us
through it. This London of 1897 is a world away from the London I wrote about
in 1859. Confident, modern in a way that is recognisable to those of us who
knew the city in the 20th century, a society and a city comfortable on the
cutting edge of technology, assured of its natural right to rule over much of
the world. The appalling callousness towards the lives of the poor which had
characterised London only fifty years earlier has passed. The poor are still
poor, as the author frequently reminds us, but few of them are dying of
starvation in the streets. Proper sewerage, the availability of clean water and
improvements in housing mean that life may be grim but it is civilised.
Against this
broader background of London life Spencer draws a more detailed picture of some
aspects of the city, particularly of "Little Russia" in the East End.
I was unaware of the number of Russian emigres who had formed their own world
in the alien land of London, complete with shops selling Russian food and banks
catering for those wanting to transfer money back to families at home in the
East. It was a fascinating glimpse of a bit of London’s history that was
completely new to me.
Spencer's
research is extensive and her descriptions of people and places are convincing
without suffering from long paragraphs which mark out the less sophisticated
historical novelist, determined to shovel in all the research that they have
done. There is perhaps an element of this in the detailed descriptions of Queen
Victoria's Jubilee parade, but it must have been a splendid sight and I think
we can forgive anybody who wants to dwell on it at length. And it does come at
a crucial moment in the plot.
As far as
the plot goes, it's more thriller than detective story. The villains leave a
chain of corpses for the detectives to follow and eventually they are tracked
and their evil plan is foiled in the nick of time. [No real spoilers there.]
The plot relies rather heavily on a deus
ex machina figure to appear at moments of crisis and there is a
conveniently helpful love interest to explain life in Little Russia to our
inspector, but these tropes are well within the rules of the genre and I was
happy to go along with them. Indeed I was happy to go along with the whole
thing, as Ms Spencer has an easy writing style that carries you effortlessly
through a plot filled with incident.
The best
historical fiction, I think, should entertain while giving you some insight
into a past world that you might not be familiar with. Blackstone and the Rendezvous with Death does exactly that and
Spencer is to be congratulated on her achievement. If I have one quibble it is
the opening. The book starts with a prologue in which a character is chased
through the streets of London on a dark foggy night until the murderer catches
up with him and the foul deed is done. There seems to be a fashion at the
moment for insisting that books should start with "something
exciting". Hence prologues like this. It doesn't add to the story and,
possibly because the author doesn't really believe in it, it is one of the
least well written and least convincing parts of the whole book. It nearly put me
off reading it. If it annoys you, just skip it altogether: it will make no
difference whatsoever to your enjoyment of what follows.